Cotton Wick vs. Wooden Wick Candles: Which Is Better?

Candles have been a part of human culture for centuries, serving not only as a source of light but also as a means to create a cozy and relaxing atmosphere. Today, candles come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and materials, including the type of wick used.

Among the most popular are cotton wicks and wooden wicks. Each type of wick offers a unique burning experience, and choosing the right one depends on personal preferences and specific needs.

In this blog, we'll explore the differences between cotton wick and wooden wick candles, weighing their pros and cons to help you decide which is better for you.

The Basics: Cotton Wicks

Cotton wicks are the traditional choice for candles and have been used for centuries. They are typically made from braided cotton fibers, sometimes with a core of paper or zinc to help them stand upright in the wax. Here are some key characteristics of cotton wick candles:

Pros of Cotton Wicks:

  1. Consistency: Cotton wicks provide a consistent burn, making them reliable for a steady flame.
  2. Widely Available: Cotton wick candles are more common and can be found in almost any store that sells candles.
  3. Versatile: They can be used in a variety of candle types, including jar candles, votives, and pillars.
  4. Low Maintenance: Cotton wicks require minimal maintenance and are easy to trim to the desired length.

Cons of Cotton Wicks:

  1. Soot Production: Cotton wicks can produce more soot than wooden wicks, which may discolor the candle jar and surrounding area.
  2. Uneven Burning: If not trimmed properly, cotton wicks can cause uneven burning, leading to tunneling or excess wax residue.
  3. Limited Aesthetic: Cotton wicks lack the visual appeal and novelty of wooden wicks.

The Basics: Wooden Wicks

Wooden wicks are a more recent innovation in the candle industry. They are made from thin strips of wood, often sourced from sustainable forests. Wooden wick candles offer a unique and modern twist on traditional candles. Here are some key characteristics of wooden wick candles:

Pros of Wooden Wicks:

  1. Crackling Sound: One of the most distinctive features of wooden wicks is the soft crackling sound they produce, similar to a fireplace, which adds to the ambiance.
  2. Clean Burn: Wooden wicks tend to produce less soot than cotton wicks, resulting in a cleaner burn.
  3. Unique Aesthetic: Wooden wicks create a wider, more luminous flame, enhancing the visual appeal of the candle.
  4. Eco-Friendly: Many wooden wicks are made from sustainably sourced wood, making them an environmentally friendly option.

Cons of Wooden Wicks:

  1. Higher Cost: Wooden wick candles can be more expensive than their cotton wick counterparts due to the materials and manufacturing process involved.
  2. Harder to Light: Wooden wicks can be more challenging to light, especially if they are too short or have absorbed moisture.
  3. Less Versatile: Wooden wicks are not suitable for all types of candles, particularly smaller ones where the flame might be too large.

Comparing Burn Time and Performance

The burn time and performance of a candle largely depend on the quality of the wick and the type of wax used. Both cotton and wooden wick candles can offer long burn times if made correctly. However, there are some differences worth noting:

  • Burn Time: Cotton wick candles generally burn longer because the wick consumes less wax per hour compared to wooden wicks. This makes them ideal for those who want a candle that lasts for extended periods.
  • Flame Size and Heat: Wooden wick candles produce a larger flame and more heat, which can create a more intense scent throw. This makes them perfect for quickly filling a room with fragrance.
  • Wax Pool: Wooden wicks tend to create a wider wax pool, which can help in burning the candle more evenly and reducing leftover wax. Cotton wicks might require more careful trimming and maintenance to achieve an even burn.

Scent Throw

The scent throw of a candle refers to how well the fragrance disperses throughout a room. Both cotton and wooden wick candles can provide excellent scent throw, but there are some differences:

  • Cotton Wicks: Cotton wicks provide a steady and consistent release of fragrance, making them suitable for smaller spaces or for those who prefer a subtle scent.
  • Wooden Wicks: The larger flame and higher heat of wooden wicks can enhance the scent throw, making them ideal for larger rooms or for those who enjoy a more robust fragrance experience.

Maintenance and Care

Proper maintenance is essential for getting the most out of your candles, regardless of the wick type. Here are some tips for each:

Cotton Wicks:

  • Trim Regularly: Keep the wick trimmed to about 1/4 inch to prevent excessive soot and uneven burning.
  • Avoid Drafts: Place the candle in an area free from drafts to maintain a steady flame and even burn.
Wooden Wicks:
  • Trim Carefully: Wooden wicks should be trimmed to about 1/8 inch before each use. Use a wick trimmer or nail clippers for precise trimming.
  • Proper Lighting: When lighting a wooden wick, hold the flame to the base of the wick for a few seconds to ensure it lights evenly.

Environmental Impact

When considering the environmental impact of candles, it's important to look at the materials used for both the wick and the wax. Wooden wick candles are often marketed as eco-friendly due to the sustainable sourcing of wood. However, the overall environmental impact also depends on the type of wax used (e.g., soy, beeswax, paraffin).

Cotton Wicks:

  • Material: Cotton wicks are biodegradable and can be sourced sustainably, though some may contain a metal or paper core.
  • Wax Compatibility: Cotton wicks can be used with a variety of waxes, including more environmentally friendly options like soy or beeswax.

Wooden Wicks:

  • Material: Wooden wicks are typically made from natural wood and are often sourced from FSC-certified forests.
  • Eco-Friendly Appeal: When paired with natural waxes, wooden wick candles can be a highly eco-friendly option.


Choosing between cotton wick and wooden wick candles ultimately comes down to personal preference and the specific qualities you're looking for in a candle.

If you prioritize a traditional, reliable, and long-lasting candle with minimal maintenance, a cotton wick candle might be the best choice.

On the other hand, if you enjoy a unique burning experience with a crackling sound and a more intense fragrance throw, a wooden wick candle could be the perfect fit.

Both types of wicks have their own set of advantages and considerations. By understanding the differences and evaluating your own needs, you can make an informed decision and enjoy the perfect candle experience.

Back to blog